Make it Meaningful: The Art of Gift Giving

Photo credit: Julie Stanley/JuleImages LLC

Photo credit: Julie Stanley/JuleImages LLC


Jewelry contains the stories of our lives. We remember the person who gifted the jewels to us or who they used to belong to and the occasions we treated ourselves, celebrated and first wore them and how they make us feel.  These bits of shiny metal, sparkling stones and other beautiful materials become opportunities for storytelling and part of our legacy as beloved jewels, and the stories that go with them, are passed down through generations. The holiday season is just around the corner so rather than write the expected “what to buy” jewelry gift guide, I want to revive the art of gift giving and offer tips for how to give the perfect jewelry gift.


Every year I always receive frantic last-minute requests from customers, typically husbands and boyfriends (sorry fellas, but it's true), asking me to select jewelry pieces for their sweetheart in a specific price range because they have no idea what their loved one wants for the holidays, anniversary or birthday.  While I’m delighted to help out, no matter the occasion, I’ve found that meaningful and treasured gifts are determined by so much more than price.  Celebrating and honoring your beloved with a special gift from the heart should bring you great joy; not be something you stress out about or mindlessly check-off your to-do list. The following tips will help you play detective and find out what jewelry gifts your partner really wants, without them suspecting a thing, and make this year's holiday season (or the next birthday and anniversary) extra memorable.


How to Pick the Perfect Jewelry Gift

 

1: Listen (put your phone away) and Listen Some More

Give your partner your full attention when you’re together.  We all want to be fully seen, fully heard, and feel valued, especially by those closest to us. Put your phones away (yes, away, not just face down on the table) and truly listen to one another. Pay close attention to comments about the things they like and enjoy.  Does their face light up at the mention of certain topics or items?  That’s a good hint for what they would enjoy receiving as a gift.

 

2: Don’t Wait Until the Last-Minute

You should be just as excited to give your gift, as your loved one will be in receiving it. If you’re not excited about giving your jewelry gift then it’s probably the wrong gift for your beloved. Part of the joy of giving jewelry is in the search, so give yourself time to find a gift that will be enjoyed for a lifetime. The story of your search becomes part of your gift and your partner will feel deeply loved and valued knowing you listened and made the time to find them a truly special treasure. You’ll feel great sense of joy and pride knowing how happy your thoughtfulness and effort made them.

 

3: Emotional Significance

Well-crafted jewelry endures for generations. To me, the perfect jewelry gift is emotionally significant to both the giver and the receiver. Is there a particular gemstone or design style that is significant to the two of you? If so, then your favorite jeweler would love knowing those details and gladly help you in finding or custom designing the perfect gift.

 

4: Part of Something Bigger

Jewelry that supports the greater good is another way to add an extra layer of love to your gift.  Purely handmade pieces are rare in our modern world. Using a variety of traditional metalsmithing techniques; forging, soldering, hand-fabricating and finishing, I design and create each piece with my own hands. My jewelry collections feature Fairmined gold and ethically sourced sterling silver and precious gemstones from artisanal small-scale miners using the most ethical and sustainable methods for protecting the health and well-being of the miners and the environment.

 

5: Artful Wrapping

Presentation is everything.  Opening a gift can be just as fun and joyful as enjoying the gift itself.  Wrapping your gift in a unique way makes it extra special and adds an additional layer of love to the experience of giving and receiving.  

 

Thanks so much for being part of our jewelry community.  One of my goals for my journal articles is to help spread beauty and joy around the world, especially during the holiday season. So, if you’ve found this article helpful, please share it via whatever social media platforms you most enjoy (share buttons are below) or even via email if that’s easiest for you. Thanks again and happiest of holidays to you and your loved ones.

If you would like some extra help in finding the perfect jewelry gift, please send me an email at info@michellepajakreynolds.com


 

Michelle Pajak-Reynolds

The creative journey of Michelle Pajak-Reynolds—from childhood spark to timeless, handcrafted treasures.

“My love story with jewelry began before I was born. My parents met across a jewelry counter—my mother, a jewelry department manager; my father, a police officer working loss prevention in his off-duty hours. That moment of serendipity set everything in motion.

By five, I was working on my first designs in pop-beads and jelly bracelets, completely captivated by Lynda Carter’s Wonder Woman—especially those iconic power bracelets and her gleaming tiara. I didn’t want to just wear magic, I wanted to make it. With babysitting money and a fierce sense of purpose, I bought beads and wire from the local craft store and taught myself the fundamentals. That curiosity turned into a calling.

I took my first metalsmithing class in high school and never looked back. I went on to earn a BFA in Jewelry/Metals from Kent State University and an MBA in Entrepreneurship from Baldwin-Wallace University—equipping me to build a business rooted in craftsmanship, creativity, and soul.

Since founding my namesake jewelry company in 2001, I’ve focused on creating meaningful, one-of-a-kind designs—each one handcrafted using traditional metalsmithing techniques and ethically sourced materials. My work is intimate and intentional: forged in fire, shaped by hand, and designed to stir something deep within you. Every gemstone, every metal, every story that inspires a collection is carefully chosen, researched, and refined. This is slow jewelry with a purpose: to help you mark what matters most.

My pieces have graced red carpets at the Emmy Awards, runways at New York Fashion Week, and exhibitions around the world—including aboard the United Nations Peace Boat. Collectors, stylists, and editors seek out my work, but what means the most to me is when a client says, “This feels like it was made just for me.”

Because it was.

Jewelry, to me, is personal mythology made tangible. It’s a way of preserving the past, celebrating the present, and passing something meaningful into the future. So when you open your jewelry box, you're not just looking at beautiful objects—you're holding pieces of your life’s story. And maybe, just maybe, you're beginning a new chapter.” - Michelle Pajak-Reynolds

michellepajakreynolds.com
Previous
Previous

Labradorite: Frozen Fire Within

Next
Next

Keep them Sparkling: 5 Things Every Jewelry Lover Should Know About Silver Tarnish